Wed, 22 Sep 2021
22.7 C
Durban

Mtentu bridge project out for tender again after roads agency wins case against ex-contractor

Home Infrastructure Construction & Civils Mtentu bridge project out for tender again after roads agency wins case...

AN appeal to prevent the South African National Roads Agency (SANRAL) from claiming guarantees from the joint venture that stopped work on the Mtentu bridge project in 2019 has been dismissed by the Supreme Court of Appeals (SCA).

The judgment on Aveng Strabag (Africa) (Pty) and Strabag International GmbH (ASJV) vs SANRAL was handed down electronically by circulation to the parties’ representatives on Friday, 13 November.

ASJV had argued that it was justified in pulling out of the contract after a work stoppage due to civil unrest at the site, saying this amounted to force majeure, unforeseeable circumstances beyond its control.

“We are happy that the court has dismissed the appeal with costs,” said Craig McLachlan, SANRAL’s N2 Wild Coast Road lead project manager. “Our position that there was no force majeure, and as the contractor refused to return to site after the suspension of works was lifted, we had no option but to terminate for abandonment of the project.”

He said SANRAL would now proceed with calling in both the performance and retention guarantees to help cover the additional costs that will be incurred to complete the project with a new contractor. “The contractor and not the taxpayer should be held liable for all additional costs.”

SANRAL had advertised the re-tender for the construction of the Mtentu River Bridge and associated roads on the N2WCR project. The re-tender closes on Friday, 19 February 2021.

According to court documents, at the heart of this appeal was whether SANRAL was restricted by the underlying contract between it and the joint venture ASJV from demanding payment in terms of a performance guarantee issued in its favour by the second respondent, Lombard Insurance Company Ltd.

The ASJV asserted that SANRAL’s call on the guarantee would be unlawful, as it had not met certain conditions in the underlying contract which limited its rights to call up the guarantee. ASJV lost this initiall case but subsequently were granted leave to appeal to the SCA. The case was heard by the SCA on 14 September 2020.

In court papers Judge TM Magoka said that the ASJV has failed to show that SANRAL was not entitled to payment of the guarantee before any underlying dispute between them is determined. Accordingly, the appeal must fail. The appeal was dismissed with costs, including the costs of two counsel.

Most Popular

Ports authority pulls plug on Ngqura liquid bulk storage terminal

TRANSNET National Ports Authority (TNPA) has pulled out of development of the proposed new liquid bulk storage terminal at the Port of Ngqura but...

R253m road project boon for EC town

THE South African National Roads Agency (SANRAL) met with the Dordrecht business fraternity recently to discuss the economic benefits and job opportunities presented by...

Council tweaks budget in bid to stop taps running dry

AS the ongoing drought continues to grip the Kouga region, Kouga Municipality Council recently adjusted its capital budget in an attempt to prevent taps...

NMB drought mitigation plans ‘in overdrive’

THE Nelson Mandela Bay Municipality’s drought mitigation plans are in overdrive as the region continues to experience insignificant rainfall and low dam levels that...